What Should You Keep When Replacing Your Old Website?

A sleek, modern workspace with a partially open laptop and a wireless mouse on a wooden desk. A minimalist chair with a black seat is tucked under the desk.

When you're planning a new website, it's tempting to think about everything you want to change. Perhaps you're ready for a completely different design, a better way to present your services or a website that feels more professional and reflects how your business has developed.

However, replacing your old website doesn't mean you should automatically get rid of everything that's already there.

Your existing site may contain valuable content, useful pages, customer reviews and search engine rankings that have taken time to build. If these are overlooked during a redesign, you could lose things that were helping your business attract visitors and generate enquiries.

Before starting again, I'd recommend reviewing the existing website carefully and deciding what should be kept, improved, moved or removed.


1. Pages that already attract visitors

One of the first things I'd look at is which pages people are actually visiting.

Your homepage might receive the most attention, but individual service pages, blog posts or location pages could also be bringing potential customers to your website through Google.

If a particular page is attracting relevant visitors, it's worth understanding why before changing or removing it. You may be able to improve the design and content while keeping the information that makes it useful.

Google Search Console and website analytics can help you identify which pages are receiving impressions, clicks and visits.


2. Content that explains your services well

You don't need to rewrite every sentence simply because you're creating a new website.

Some of your existing content might already explain your services clearly, answer common customer questions or communicate what makes your business different.

I'd review each page and decide whether the information is still accurate and useful. Keep content that works, improve sections that need updating and remove anything that no longer reflects your business.

This also gives you an opportunity to make sure your new website provides enough detail for potential customers to understand what you offer.


3. Existing page URLs

Your website's URLs are important, particularly if they've been indexed by Google or shared elsewhere online.

If you change the address of a page during a redesign, the old URL may no longer work. This can create a poor experience for visitors and affect search visibility if the change isn't handled correctly.

Where possible, I'd keep existing URLs that are still relevant. If a page needs a new address, make sure a suitable 301 redirect points the old URL to the most relevant new page.

Avoid redirecting every old page to the homepage, as this doesn't necessarily help visitors find the information they were looking for.


4. Testimonials and customer reviews

Reviews and testimonials can help build trust with people who haven't worked with your business before.

If your current website includes genuine customer feedback, consider how this can be carried across to the new design. You might want to reorganise the testimonials, make them easier to find or feature selected comments on relevant service pages.

Make sure any testimonials you reuse are genuine and that you have permission to display them where required.


5. Portfolio images and previous projects

If your business relies on showing examples of previous work, your portfolio could be one of the most valuable parts of your website.

Before replacing the site, gather the original images and review which projects best represent the quality and type of work you currently offer.

You might not need every photograph from the old website, particularly if some are outdated or poor quality. However, removing all your previous project examples could mean losing useful evidence of your experience.

A new website is a good opportunity to present your work more effectively, rather than starting with an empty portfolio.


6. Your branding and visual identity

Your new website doesn't necessarily need a completely different identity.

If customers already recognise your logo, colours and general branding, retaining some visual consistency can help make the transition feel familiar.

You may decide to modernise parts of the design, update your typography or improve your imagery, but I'd think carefully before changing everything at once.

The goal is to create a website that feels more professional while still being recognisable as your business.


7. Important functionality

Your existing website may include features that customers rely on, even if they're not immediately obvious.

This could include contact forms, booking systems, payment facilities, downloadable documents, newsletter sign-ups or integrations with other services.

Make a list of these before the rebuild begins and decide which should be carried across, improved or replaced.

It's also worth checking whether any features are no longer being used, as removing unnecessary functionality can simplify the new website.


8. Important SEO information

Alongside the content and URLs, there are other SEO details worth reviewing.

These include page titles, meta descriptions, heading structure, image alt text, internal links and any structured data already in use.

Not everything needs to remain exactly the same, but it's useful to understand what is currently in place before making changes.

If you're investing in a redesign, protecting existing search visibility should be part of the planning process.


9. Contact details and business information

This might sound obvious, but it's surprisingly easy for small details to be overlooked when moving to a new website.

Check your business email address, telephone number, address, opening hours, social media links and any other important contact information.

If your business details have changed, use the redesign as an opportunity to update them consistently across the website.


10. Blog articles and useful resources

If you've been publishing blog posts for a while, don't assume they should all be removed when the new website launches.

Some articles may continue to attract search traffic or answer questions potential customers regularly ask. Others may need updating, combining with similar articles or removing if they're no longer relevant.

Review the performance and usefulness of each post before deciding what to do with it.


How do you decide what to keep?

I'd approach the process by reviewing every existing page and placing it into one of four categories:

  • Keep: The page is still useful, accurate and relevant.

  • Improve: The information is valuable but needs updating or rewriting.

  • Combine: Several pages cover similar topics and could work better as one stronger page.

  • Remove: The page is no longer relevant and doesn't need to be carried across.

This makes the migration process much more organised and reduces the risk of accidentally removing something important.


Replacing your website without losing valuable content

A new website should improve on what you already have, not undo the progress you've made.

Taking the time to review your existing pages, content, images and SEO before starting a redesign can make a significant difference to the finished result. It also gives you a clearer idea of what needs to be created and what can be carried across.

If you're planning to replace your old website, I'd be happy to help you work out what should stay and what could be improved.


Frequently asked questions

Should I keep my old website's URLs when redesigning?

If the existing URLs are still relevant, keeping them can help avoid unnecessary changes. If you do need to change them, use appropriate 301 redirects to direct visitors and search engines to the relevant new pages.

Will I lose my Google rankings if I replace my website?

Not necessarily, but a poorly managed redesign can affect search visibility. Reviewing existing pages, retaining useful content, preserving important URLs and setting up redirects can help reduce the risk.

Should I copy all my old website content?

No. Keep content that is accurate and useful, improve anything that needs updating and remove material that is outdated or irrelevant. A redesign is a good opportunity to improve the quality of your website.

How do I know which website pages are important?

Look at website analytics and Google Search Console to understand which pages attract visitors, receive search impressions and generate enquiries. Also consider whether a page answers an important customer question or supports one of your services.